8/17/2008
Switching from Thunderbird (sniff) to Mail.app
After being a stalwart user of Thunderbird, and all (yes, all) its predecessors, I have finally had enough of the slow progress and flaky alphas that TB has been sporting for the last 6 or so months. I have now switched to Mail.app, and while I miss certain things in TB, the fact that I can reliably read attached documents drove me to the switch. Plus, QuickLook really rocks.
My main issue with switching is/was filtering. Mail.app’s filtering is OK, but it is missing the crucial (for me, anyway) ability to filter based on the ‘read’ status of a message. I like to read messages to some mailing lists as they arrive, and then move them to their folder after I’ve read them. Thunderbird lets you do this easily, by setting up a filter that moves messages for the mailing list (like subject contains ‘[Petunia Growers]’) where the message status is ‘read’. Run all filters for your inbox, and the messages you have read are squirreled away in your archive folder.
I semi-solved this issue using the Mail Act-on plugin for Mail.app. It allows you to set up filters that are only run when the user requests them to be run. So now I select all messages in my inbox (Cmd-A), then hit the backtick (`), and a letter corresponding to the types of messages I want to filter out. This moves all the messages that match (sadly disregarding the ‘read’ status of messages). So I can move messages away quickly, but it is still a blunt instrument compared to TB’s filtering.
If anyone at Apple reads this, please, please, please add the ‘read status’ as a filterable item. That would make me a total convert!
Secondly, I was annoyed to find that Mail.app only does top-posting in replies. Yuck! TB had a nice option to let you do either. Daring Fireball has an old posting that creates a fix for this deficiency. It does require you to use FastScript (a $15 utility that helps you manage AppleScripts). I suppose you could do the same thing with Automator, but I have never had the patience to learn how to use it. And that weird robot thing bugs me…
Filed by pthomsen at 2:58 pm under Technology
No Comments